San Jose-based nonprofits have reignited their legal battle against the city’s use of Flock Safety license plate readers (LPRs), raising fresh concerns about privacy and surveillance. The organizations argue that the widespread deployment of these devices by law enforcement infringes on civil liberties, claiming it amounts to unwarranted mass surveillance of residents without sufficient oversight or transparency. Their renewed lawsuit asserts that Flock’s technology collects and retains data indiscriminately, tracking movements of thousands of innocent individuals daily.

Key issues highlighted in the case include:

  • Data retention policies: How long and in what manner license plate information is stored.
  • Access and usage: Who can access the data and for what purposes.
  • Community impact: Potential chilling effects on public freedom and privacy.
AspectNonprofits’ PositionCity’s Defense
Surveillance ScopeIndiscriminate, affecting all residentsTargeted, focused on crime prevention
Data SecurityInsufficient safeguards against misuseEncrypted & limited access protocols
TransparencyLack of public disclosureRegular reports and audits